My dogs LOVE these! They will train on and on because they like them so much. These are easily the most high value treat in our house. Wish they were less on the spendy side, but all freeze dried food is.My 10yo husky was recently diagnosed with idiopathic epilepsy and is on medication twice daily. As a picky eater she's always refused standard dog treats and pretty much turned her nose up at pill pockets. These chicken hearts seem to be her new favorite treat and have just the right sized hole in the top for me to slide her capsule pill into and she's none the wiser! It's a solid win for both of us! They definitely stink but as soon as I open the bag she knows it's treat time.Wanted to love these more but slightly disappointed. My dog loves bully sticks so I decided to buy these, my dog loves them but they are more like a treat not a bone. He can eat one in about 1 minuteI bought the minows, the beef livers and chicken hearts for the dog. They are the perfect size training treats. Well I gave him the minows and he was obsessed, then he got the beef livers and was even more obsessed. Well the last ones we tried were the chicken hearts and he goes crazy for these! As a human they all kinda smell but the smell is gone as soon as they eat it and it doesn't make their breathe smell. But these are the treats for picky eaters our there and those dogs who will do anything for a treat! Will continue to buy!They are healthy single ingredient treats and my 2 dogs and cats love them. My outside feral kitties love them too!My 11 year dog is extremely picky. She loves the treats. I try to only buy products that are made in the United States. I read that freeze-drying also helps preserve nutrients better than the typical baking process that uses high heat. My two dogs love them.The dogs like them, that is what counts. Plus, I like that they are small so low calories when training the dogs.My dog really loves these. I use them for training and snacks.These are a little expensive but you can't buy them in this country so I have to order them. So worth it to me though as my dogs are addicted to them and they are super healthy. postage is free so that's a plus and they seem to dispatch immediately as I get them pretty quickly considering they come from the states.A great treat for raw fed dogs and they come really well packaged.The real McCoy! Vital Essentials Is the best of the best and this is why we are forced to buy from the USA because we can't get such quality products from the UK. I wish we could catch on but the average person has no idea that raw food is biologically appropriateWorth paying a little more for something all natural and super healthy, free postage and pretty quick delivery thoughMy dogs are addicted!These are fresh, natural, and made in the USA. The only inconvenience is when trying to break them apart to treat small dogs. As they are rather greasy it's tough to do the snap-tear that their other varieties allow. These are rather wet and pliable vs dry and rigid. Nevertheless, I'd rather have these treats vs many of the other made-elsewhere treats.