This is my dog's favorite treat.. she will sit by where I store these and stare me down to remind me if I forget to give her one every day.She does a happy little excited hop when I give her one. She's a picky dog and will refuse some treats, but always wants these.These are a good size and take her longer to eat than typical rawhide or other treats. One a day keeps her teeth and gums in good shape.They're not odor free, but they smell more beefy than stinky so not a bad odor. Anything that doesn't smell at all has been heavily bleached and treated with chemicals which is not good for the dog to eat, so I'd prefer more natural treats like this.I wish they were cheaper, but they're really high quality, a good size, keep her teeth/gums in good shape and last a long time, so all told they're worth it.Product description is deceptive as it states that a 0.5 lbs bag of 12” sticks contains approximately 7-9 sticks. My order only contained 5. When I reached out to the seller, their only answer was that the product is sold by weight. I will say that the sticks themselves are of high quality; just not the amount I expected to receive.As the guardian of countless fosters and several of my own power chewers, being able to buy these in bulk is a HUGE help and money saver. They are extremely low odor, have varying thickness for all of our pups, and last even our toughest chewers at least 10-15 minutes, though average and minimal chewers can have them for hours!These bully sticks are perfect for smaller dogs. They are uniform in length and diameter. They are not advertised as low odor but smell about the same as those that are sold as low odor bully sticks. I would order them again.These star ratings are deceiving... They’re thin, stinky and don’t last too long for my large power chewers, but that’s exactly why I buy them! Two of my crew will swallow large pieces and could choke themselves-these are too thin for that, which is perfect! And they love the stink-that’s part of the joy of a bully stick for them. Just don’t let them get eaten on your furniture and you’re good.I'm always looking for a good deal on BullySticks and these worked well. Last a decent length of time and the puppers loves them. He stares at his food then immediately looks for a stick....smart little jerkMy dog loved these to start with but soon got tired of chewing them. I cut them in half & that seems to be a better size for her.I have a small Jack Russell (12 years old) and a even smaller, almost toothless, Yorkie (14 years old) who love these. The Jack Russell will spend over an hour on one of these. I soak the end of one to soften it to get my Yorkie started. Two very happy dogs. Wished I had found them earlier!I purchased these for my 4 month old pup who has had bully sticks before. The package arrived with contents looking nothing like the pictures. They had a strong smell (like cheese) She chewed for awhile and I heard crunching! Unusual. She got a piece off(6 lb pup) and this concerned me so I took it away. The next day she would not chew anything that wasn't soft so I think it hurt her mouth. I am returning them.My dogs are obsessed with these! I have three dogs and I’ve bought them so many different types of bones. These are the only ones that will keep them busy for hours! Such a lifesaver.My puppy likes these and it takes him a while to get through it. They are different thicknesses but they do smell. I bought the 5lb bag for the price which will last months.The product advertised un picture is not product u get , in picture product flat , actual product rounded like tree twigs