This review has been rated by the amount of drool left on my knee by my sweet wolfdog when I held the treat in front of his face. Probably would get ten stars by that measure.Anyway, with both wolf kids loving these (milk bones are not even in the same galaxy as this stuff) what can I say? I don't eat them. Evidently they are not unhealthful for the "kids" so it seems like a win-win to me. I'll be back for more very soon, these are some hefty sized wolfdogs.Our 10 month old puppy really likes these but I wish they were bigger so that they would last longer. He is a big chewer so longevity in a treat is important.These are a little stinkier than I care for, but I am very sensitive to smells. My English lab puppy loves these and they keep her happy and entertained for quite a while so that I can leave her alone.I have big Goldens and they go through these quickly but they love them.My German Shepherd likes these more than other brands.Special treat for when we have to leave them home.My dog is super picky and he loves these!But beware they are suuuuper stinky. I had to put them in a better airtight bag so they didn’t stink up my house.Ollie’s birthday gift.. he loves them.