One of my favorite products to use for my pup (Pug Mix, healthy & athletic 30lbs). He loves the taste and has no issue happily accepting them like a normal treat. The ingredients are natural, and I especially love that there is no melatonin or hemp*. (*not against hemp at all, just use it in another supplement with more control on dosing). These work great, but take note of dosing & the size of your dog. Larger dogs will most definitely need more to get a proper dose & affect. My pup has on 2 occasions gotten into a treat bag that had a weeks amount; but there was absolutely no concerning affects--no digestive issues, tiredness but totally alert. (Always monitor your pet if this happens, contact a vet if concerned—every dog is different!)I usually buy these 2 at time, and will continue to do so unless there is magically a better product for a lower price point!