I have a reactive dog who is currently in training. He’s doing much better, but we constantly run into issues when we get trapped in the lobby of my apartment with other dogs. The enclosed space and lack of distance is very difficult for him and I struggle to get him to engage with me no matter what I offer him. However, as soon as I started breaking these up to use as training treats he has improved by a TON. Apparently he would move mountains for a single scrap of a chicken meatball. We have been able to walk past or be around other dogs in the lobby on 3 separate occasions now with little to no reaction. Every time I was giving him these treats. So to any of my reactive dog parents, give these a shot. I think the strong smell and texture is irresistible or something.