My dog doesn’t like the wishbone style bones. These don’t have a funky stench like some cheaper/low quality brands. She’s a tough chewer and this will occupy her for about 7 mins. Good value! I hide them around the house and she tracks them :) will buy again!wish it were less money, how can I rate the flavor, my dog eats them not meI have a very old Pyrenees mix. He is literally the dog version of grumpy old men. He just wants to lay on the porch in the sun, get pets, and have his dinner fed to him on silver platter every night. In his old age, he has gotten very picky with eating. I guess now that he is old he doesn't want to waste his time on mediocre treats. He turns his nose up to bacon treats, biscuits, and the latest..pumpkin cookies. However, I offered him one of these treats and he took it immediately. He also became a drool factory while eating it. He occupied him for about 5 minutes but he is a large (XL really ) dog and still has great teeth. I wish they came in larger packaging or bulk discount pricing. I gave them a one star for scent...because they don't smell at all which I think is a good thing. There was no odor when he was chewing the treat and he didn't have smelly breathe afterwards.Our 12 year old golden loves these beef gullet sticks. I have been giving her 2 each day for about a year, and they do not have an offensive odor. These treats are great for a senior dog even though they are devoured quickly. She no longer can chew bully sticks and prefers the hollow gullet sticks. The only recommendation that I would make is to label the bag 15 or 30 since I received a bag of 15 sticks the first time that I ordered even though I paid for 30 sticks. I order a bag of 30 every 2 weeks and intend to keep buying! Thank you for such a high quality treat for my sweet girl.My little angel loves these. I give them as treats. They are pricier than I hoped for, but so are most things today.my dogs enjoy themSeriously, what are you guys putting in these things? Cocaine for dogs? My golden retriever will drop any toy/treat, for one of these - and he INHALES them...I'M not eating them - so I won't be rating the "flavor" of them - they don't have a noxious odor - if that's what you're asking there....and they don't seem to effect his breath.Great product from EcoKind. These have absolutely NO smell to them that I could discern. My dogs, however, instantly came running when I opened the bag.Each dog is 55# and they devoured their treats within 30 minutes. They all have touchy stomachs and these didn't bother them at all. Easily digestible and perfect size, even for my big girls.This is a pet treat, not a pet chew.Have a puppy, a Singapore special, about 4 months and less than 10 kg.He absolutely loves these.I give him half a stick at a time, about 3 inches, and he gets through it in about 5-10 minutes.We got a very nasty surprise when we opened the bag - there was a big beetle and a pupal case inside.
