My dog loved it and my in-law's older, finicky dog who usually doesn't like vegan treats loved them too.Smells great.My Vegan dogs love them!Our dog Carnaby is so picky and he loves these treats! I love their mission too. Huge fans over here!I ordered these for my dog with chronic pancreatitis because he has to be on a low fat diet or he gets very sick (can’t keep food down). But i love that they are plant based and vegan. My dogs LOVE the taste, the Brats are probably their favorite. I like that they are small and soft and i can rewards them frequently ?. These are going on autoship.My dog isn't allowed any extra meat protein outside of his veterinary diet. These look and smell like meat TREATS. Do not feed your dog a vegan diet.These are great for dogs like mine.As vegans with a dog, we want to be ethical when buying training treats... But they still have to motivate the dog! These are his favorite and I love that I can get the multipack.For occasional treats, they're the perfect size. For training, I use a knife and cut into 2-4 pieces depending on the treat. (2 for brats, 3 for bbq chkn, 4 for burgers)These treats smell good enough for me to eat, and my finicky pups absolutely love them. So happy I bought these and will continue to buy more.